The Illinois River at Two Rivers National Wildlife Refuge was over its banks in a typical spring flood. I canoed through the forest about a foot above ground. Filtered sunlight gave the woods an almost phosphorescent light green glow; humidity was low; mosquitoes absent. These were perfect conditions to simply sit and listen to the discordant croakings and other bizarre sounds coming from the great blue heron rookery above my head.
Then, just when the thought struck that I was within the wildest, most primeval place in Illinois, where natural rhythms of the river reign supreme, the strangest, growling sound of all commanded my attention. The sound came not from herons, but from two red-headed woodpeckers vying for a coveted hole near the top of a standing dead tree (snag). Although red-headed woodpeckers are abundant along the river, and on that day all seemed right, in fact, the red-headed woodpecker has been declining in Illinois by nearly 2 percent per year. I was not sure, but I suspected perhaps the decline might have something to do with most of Illinois being just about the opposite of wild and primeval. In effect, the woodpeckers delivered an environmental message to me that I found troubling. I felt compelled to begin a search for more information.
Habitats
One of the most unusual behaviors one would expect a woodpecker to engage in is flycatching for insects. Woodpeckers are expert at climbing trees. In general, though, they appear much less agile in flight compared to tyrant flycatchers or any of the swallows. Yet leaving a foraging perch to pick out an insect from the air, sometimes after a convoluted chase, is a common foraging technique for red-headed woodpeckers during the breeding season. This type of behavior requires open habitats with widely spaced trees. Indeed, the cavity-nesting red-headed woodpecker is often characterized as a bird of savannas, a transitional habitat type between true prairie, totally lacking in trees, and closed-canopy forest. But since most of Illinois’ savannas have long been replaced with developed landscapes, breeding red-heads have adapted to other types of open landscapes, including farm country, which serve as surrogates for the missing savannas. I have often observed red-heads flying across agricultural fields, eventually landing on a wooden utility pole, flying from pole to pole, and hawking for insects over the fields and roads. In some instances, they may return after a catch to the original foraging perch. Perhaps the utility poles form the same function as scattered standing dead timber in their original savanna habitats.
Hawking red-heads can also be found along Illinois’ rivers, lakes, and wetlands. Floodplain woodlands along the Illinois River, in particular, appear to provide ideal breeding habitat. The floodplain woodlands have suffered greatly in recent years from frequent flooding. But this has given rise to an abundance of snags and has caused most floodplain woodlands to have a rather open aspect.
Snag along the Illinois River at Chautauqua National Wildlife Refuge.
And, of course, nesting sites must be easy to located in the open floodplain woodlands, given the great abundance of large snags and large living trees with dead limbs. Even logs lying and decaying upon the forest floor enhance foraging opportunities, as decaying timber normally harbors an abundance of insect life. Dead wood, without doubt, is an important habitat feature of living woodlands. In fact, red-headed woodpeckers may even be absent from wooded areas lacking snags. And given a choice, red-heads may actually prefer to forage on dead rather then live trees.
Oak snags are particularly valuable to wildlife because they tend to last longer than snags of other tree species. Larger specimens last the longest. In addition, the furrowed bark of oaks provides a larger surface area for insects to hide compared with smooth-barked species such as maple. Oaks also produce nutritious mast in the form of acorns. And, for overwintering red-headed woodpeckers, abundant mast is an absolute necessity.
Yet not all oak-hickory woodlands and forests produce abundant fruit every year. Mast years, when many individual oak trees within the same area produce a great number of acorns all at the same time, typically occur only every two to five years. Moreover, species in the red oak group (black, blackjack, pin, red) require 18 months to produce an acorn, compared with six to eight months for species in the white oak group (bur, post, white). To complicate the situation even further, mast years appear to be induced by a variety of unpredictable, interacting environmental factors such as temperature regime, light duration and intensity, and nutrient and water availability. The end result is that, from year to year, a good mast crop is unreliable.
Red-headed woodpeckers have adapted to this unreliability by evolving migratory behavior. Other species of woodpeckers, such as the downy and red-bellied, may overwinter in their breeding territories. If mast is not available, though, red-heads will migrate after the breeding season. I have readily observed this phenomenon in the floodplain woodlands along the Illinois River – which usually are dominated by silver maple, green ash, and cottonwood – because these areas tend to have a high density of red-headed woodpeckers in the summer, but lack the species during the fall and winter. Many red-heads move south to the comparatively heavily forested parts of southern Illinois, which has a higher density of overwintering red-heads than the rest of the state. Others find sites with heavy acorn crops in smaller wooded areas. During winter, red-heads may occupy forests that are much less open than their breeding habitats because insects are mostly inactive, and the hawking foraging strategy is seldom used.
How soon red-headed woodpeckers detect a mast year in progress is not known. But by late fall, they begin to enter one of two major phases of winter behavior. The first phase involves claiming and defending small territories, one per bird, and storing acorns within their territories. (Although acorns are without a doubt the most important mast used by red-headed woodpeckers, they have been known to store beechnuts, pecans, and even grasshoppers.)
Sand Prairie-Scrub Oak Nature Preserve (1,460 acres) is about three miles east of the small Illinois River town of Bath in Mason County. The woodlands and savannas of the preserve are dominated by black oak and blackjack oak (plus hybrids of the two species). The open woodlands provide good red-head habitat for breeding as well as overwintering. During some winters, red-heads appear to be completely absent. Then, in other years, they seem to be the most common overwintering woodpecker species in the preserve. During mast years, I have sometimes heard their "quirr"calls from throughout most of the preserve’s woodlands. Their territories appear to be not large; and, because the woods are open with little underbrush, sometimes from a single vantage point it is possible to see two or three individuals on different territories. Studies at other sites documented territory sizes to be from about one tenth of an acre to five acres. Territory size is apparently flexible in order to respond to the amount of mast available; that is, during poor acorn production years, larger territories would be necessary, and conversely.
Red-headed woodpeckers use snags to store acorns and other mast. After their initial caches are complete, the red-heads enter the second phase of winter behavior. This consists of long periods of quiet time perching, and time spent defending their territories and restoring their caches of acorns. The birds apparently move some of their acorns to other caches in accordance with the well known adage of not keeping all of one’s eggs in one basket. Even with a strategy of aggressive territorial defense, where a single red-head will drive off any bird that it perceives to be a competitor (blue jay, tufted titmouse, white-breasted nuthatch, or red-bellied woodpecker), piracy is common. Sometimes red-headed woodpeckers may even cover their acorn store with slivers of wood torn from snags. If the slivers are slightly damp, they will form a nice seal upon drying. Another tactic for protecting acorn supplies is to hammer the acorns into the deep furrows of oak trees, which few birds are able to remove.
Sand Prairie-Scrub Oak Nature Preserve is another of those rare and diminishing areas in Illinois still wild enough to give a sense of the original Illinois landscape. Frequent fires (actually controlled burns) have left their mark on the landscape. Ultimately, and taken to the extreme, fire favors grassland over trees. Though black and blackjack oaks at the preserve have thick bark and are fairly fire resistant, they are not totally immune from damage. And if a collection of fallen branches, twigs, and leaves have gathered at the base of a tree, a hot fire can do extensive damage. Eventually a fire-damaged tree will have fire scars, where fungi and bacteria can enter, and dead branches and dead wood within the trunk where parts of the tree can break off during strong winds. But like the standing dead timber in the Illinois River’s floodplain woodlands, snags and fire-damaged trees in these upland oak woodlands play a necessary role in maintaining the ecological health of the system as a whole. There may even be an equilibrium established whereby snags are lost to decay at about the same rate at which they are created by natural processes, such as fire and disease.
Sand Prairie-Scrub Oak Nature Preserve, Mason Co., Illinois.
I once stood at Sand Prairie-Scrub Oak Nature Preserve over the faint, lightly tinted image of a log in charred dust – all that was lift of the log following a fire of major proportions. The image suggested that even within this complex mix of destruction, ecological balance, and rebirth, the red-headed woodpecker has made a home for thousands of years. It was so unlike the modern human relationship with the natural landscape, where we are like uninvited guests who disrupt our host’s normal routines, overstay our welcome, and have no intention of leaving. And so, now it is necessary for all of us to find a way to live together.
[Note 1: For images of the red-headed woodpecker and more information, see Cornell University’s Laboratory of Ornithology web site All About Birds at http://www.birds.cornell.edu/AllAboutBirds/BirdGuide/Red-headed_Woodpecker.html.]
[Note 2: This story originally appeared in slightly different form in the fall 2000 issue of Illinois Audubon magazine, number 274.]